Quote:
Originally Posted by Nick Papageorgio
What's your roster look like? If you have to replace Phillips with some below average 2nd baseman, then it's a definant no on the trade. I wouldn't be thrilled about giving up a top 3 2nd baseman and a pretty good shortstop for a very good outfielder and an aging shortstop with recent injury problems. You also have to think that Maggs isn't going to hit .360 again this year.
|
Thanks, that's pretty much where I am coming from.
I don't like the SS part of the deal. I could live with the loss at 2B although it would probebly be a bad idea now that I really stop and think about it. I had a piss-poor team last year and I don't want to go through that again. I trhk I have a decent squad this year:
C Iván Rodríguez
(Det - C) CUtilBN 141/502 50 11 63 2 .281
1B Adrián González
(SD - 1B) 1BUtilBN 182/646 101 30 100 0 .282
2B Brandon Phillips
(Cin - 2B) 2BUtilBN 187/650 107 30 94 32 .288
3B Miguel Cabrera
(Det - 3B) 3BUtilBN 188/588 91 34 119 2 .320
SS Troy Tulowitzki
(Col - SS) SSUtilBN 177/609 104 24 99 7 .291
OF Vladimir Guerrero
(LAA - OF) OFUtilBN 186/574 89 27 125 2 .324
OF Curtis Granderson
(Det - OF) DL OFUtilBNDL 185/612 122 23 74 26 .302
OF Juan Pierre
(LAD - OF) OFUtilBN 196/668 96 0 41 64 .293
Util Josh Hamilton
(Tex - OF) OFUtilBN 87/298 52 19 47 3 .292
BN Jeremy Hermida
(Fla - OF) OFUtilBN 127/429 54 18 63 3 .296
BN Frank Thomas
(Tor - Util) UtilBN 147/531 63 26 95 0 .277
Pitching
Pos Edit Pitchers Edit Opp Status IP W SV K ERA WHIP
SP Dan Haren
(Ari - SP) SPPBN 222.2 15 0 192 3.07 1.21
SP Carlos Zambrano
(ChC - SP) SPPBN 216.1 18 0 177 3.95 1.33
RP Billy Wagner
(NYM - RP) RPPBN 68.1 2 34 80 2.63 1.13
RP Trevor Hoffman
(SD - RP) RPPBN 57.1 4 42 44 2.98 1.12
P Ben Sheets
(Mil - SP) SPPBN 141.1 12 0 106 3.82 1.24
P Jason Isringhausen
(StL - RP) RPPBN 65.1 4 32 54 2.48 1.07
P Tim Hudson
(Atl - SP) SPPBN 224.1 16 0 132 3.33 1.22
BN Jeremy Bonderman
(Det - SP) SPPBN 174.1 11 0 145 5.01 1.38
BN Ted Lilly
(ChC - SP) SPPBN 207.0 15 0 174 3.83 1.14
BN Rich Harden
(Oak - SP) SPPBN 25.2 1 0 27 2.45 1.13
BN Jeremy Guthrie
(Bal - SP,RP) SPRPPBN 175.1 7 0 123 3.70 1.21
BN Mark Buehrle
(CWS - SP) SPPBN 201.0 10 0 115 3.63 1.26