FF Trade Advice

[MSUchick77]

A trade was proposed to me this morning...what do you think? I really like Schaub.

The proposed trade:
Matt Schaub and Alexander for Romo and McGahee.

The rest of my team...
QBMatt Schaub
WRChad Johnson
WRDonte' Stallworth
RBShaun Alexander
RBMarion Barber III
TETony Gonzalez
W/RPlaxico Burress
BNEli Manning
BNDeuce McAllister
BNLadell Betts
BNIsaac Bruce
BNReuben Droughns
BNBrady Quinn
KJohn Kasay
BNJosh Brown
DEFCarolina

And his..
Q Tony Romo
WR Andre Johnson
WR Randy Moss
RB Frank Gore
RB Willis McGahee
TE Jason Witten
W/R Maurice Jones-Drew
BN Marc Bulger
BN Brandon Jackson
BN Braylon Edwards
BN Vincent Jackson
BN Chris Brown
BN Santonio Holmes
BN Derrick Ward
K Jason Elam
D New England

[MSU ROX]

Tough choice.. definitly an upgrade for you at QB.

McGahee vs Alexander...

Well, McGahee should see the end zone eventually, since Baltimores passing game is mediocre at best.

Alexander is overrated in my opinion.

I say do it....Romo is a stud.

However, if things fall apart... dont blame me.

Edit: now that I think about it...Shaub has a pretty good upside as well. Damn.... I dunno, chick...

[worm]

schaub for romo. keep alexander.

[T.C.O.B.]

I would not do it.........Romo has overperformed these first 2 weeks. McGahee is not in the same category as Alexander. Schaub has been excellent thus far for Houston. Alexander is a yardage hog and will score a lot of TDs. McGahee goes not get much receiving yards and will not come close to Alexander in TDs. I think Schaub and Romo are pretty even.

Look what you would do to his team if you did this deal........His RBs would be Gore and Alexander (yours would be McGahee and Barber). If he wants Alexander, ask for Gore. Or offer McCallister instead of Alexander (if you want McGahee).

By the way, how many people in your league? 4 ?

[MSUchick77]

Originally Posted by T.C.O.B.

I would not do it.........Romo has overperformed these first 2 weeks. McGahee is not in the same category as Alexander. Schaub has been excellent thus far for Houston. Alexander is a yardage hog and will score a lot of TDs. McGahee goes not get much receiving yards and will not come close to Alexander in TDs. I think Schaub and Romo are pretty even.

Look what you would do to his team if you did this deal........His RBs would be Gore and Alexander (yours would be McGahee and Barber). If he wants Alexander, ask for Gore. Or offer McCallister instead of Alexander (if you want McGahee).

By the way, how many people in your league? 4 ?

Thanks. I've asked a few people and most said it was decent if I wanted to trade. We have 10, 3 of us are girls. 2 of the girls have never played FF before.

[cickyle]

Don't do it. You would be trading the best player (alexander) at a low point and thus paying for a guy in Rmo who is at his high point. Schuab is good enough and Alexander has the potentials to be a stud and should end up being considerably better then Willis. If you still want to deal, I would consider asking for Bulger instead of Schuab and see if you can get one of his better bench players too.

[Spar10sby13]

NO NO NO NO NO

Alexander is back, trade for Willis??...no way. Your givin up more points at RB than you'd make at QB. Besides Schaub isn't doing all that bad, though the ankle injury to Andre Johnson hurts.

Looking at your roster you need to worry more about your WR's. Bruce is just not producing and Stallworth has been a bust thus far frankly I'm not sure why you even have him at #2 IMO