trade advice

[haveacigar535]

trade question:

I recently received a trade offer in a dynasty league (keep all players, no redraft). The trade as offered is Francisco Liriano and Jeremy Hermida for Shaun Marcum and Brian Bannister
my team:
C: Johjima
1B: Delgado
2B: K. Johnson
3B: Kouzmanoff
SS: Furcal
OF: Matt Kemp, Francoeur, Hamilton
Util: Garko, Sheffield
Bench: Jeff Kent, Iwamura, Adam LaRoche
DL: Granderson

SP: Marcum, Edwin Jackson, Oliver Perez, Gorzelanny, Bannister, Phil Hughes, Matt Cain, Carlos Zambrano, Meche, Buehrle
RP: Accardo, Mark Lowe, Tony Pena, Joakim Soria
DL: JJ Putz

His team:
C: Napoli
1B: Howard
2B: Figgins
3B: Aramis Ramirez
SS: Jeter
OF: Burrell, McLouth, Ankiel
Util: Carlos Pena, Torii Hunter
Bench: Swisher, Keppinger, Dunn, Hermida

SP: Blanton, Webb, Ubaldo Jimenez, Ervin Santana, Greinke, Blackburn, Billingsley, Wandy Rodriguez, Liriano, Carmona
RP: Corpas, Betancourt, Brian Wilson, Hoffman
DL: Shawn Hill

thinking of counter-offering for someone like Pena and upping my SP offer. any thoughts?

[AUAlum06]

if you can get Bannister do it, Lirano might never get his velocity back

[haveacigar535]

Originally Posted by AUAlum06

if you can get Bannister do it, Lirano might never get his velocity back

I already have Bannister/Marcum

[AUAlum06]

Originally Posted by haveacigar535

I already have Bannister/Marcum

I wouldn't give up either of those guys, they are both good young arms

[haveacigar535]

Originally Posted by AUAlum06

I wouldn't give up either of those guys, they are both good young arms

yeah i ended up rejecting. don't think hermida is all that great anyway.