Help re: fantasy trade proposal

[msu98]

12 team draft yesterday. I had the 7th pick, Portis slipped and I took him. Got Fred Taylor coming back around. Continued to go heavy RB and took Deuce Staley next. Three rounds later I took Steven Jackson (a stretch, but went with a gut feeling). We play a combo of 2/3 running back/wide receivers.

Today a team realized how he screwed up and is scrambling to get a RB. He offered Tory Holt straight up for Fred Taylor, after initially passing on Taylor. Here are my two potential lineups:

Trent Green
Clinton Portis
Fred Taylor
Duce Staley
Derrick Mason
Koren Robinson/Freddie Mitchelll
TE
K
De

or

Trent Green
Clinton Portis
Duce Staley
Tory Holt
Derrick Mason
Koren Robinson/Freddie Mitchell

My backup RB's are Steven Jackson and Najeh Davenport.

Would you trade Taylor for Tory Holt?

[SpartanGop]

Yes, I would, but I have to tell you that Duce will not get you anythig, I had to play him a couple of times last year and he was a non-issue, at least Davenport might score every once and a while.

[Spartan Al]

Keep Taylor.

St. Louis is in disarray. Holt is still damn good. But Bulger isn't.

[Coach McGurk]

What do you think your best course of action would be? Would it be the WR? Or the RB?

I would say keep the RB, but I am not in your shoes. They sound like awfully big shoes!

What do you think?

[CORNER BLITZ]

Keep Taylor

[izzorulesthebigten]

Whats your scoring?

Position considerations aren't that big of a factor since you can interchange Taylor for Holt. Really just matters which one will score more points. Probably Taylor, but it depends on your system.