HELP! Re: Fantasy baseball keepers

[Ernest Nzigamasabo]

I'm in a fantasy baseball keeper league . We get to keep 5 players from our roster for next year. Here is my dilemma...

Out of these players, I need to choose 1. Who should I keep?

Scott Rolen (monster number this year and a 3B, but not sure if he can repeat that next year)

Carlos Zambrano (solid young pitcher with great K's, whip, and ERA...but you usually can pick up good pitchers at any time)

Miguel Cabrera (awesome numbers in his first full season..could become a superstar..but who knows for sure)

[Heathens '87]

Rolen.....he's for real and on a solid team so the opportunities will be there. Zambrano was great, but see Zito for a warning about what can happen to pitchers. Cabrera was big, but can he repeat?!

Take the safe bet............Scott Rolen.

[sprtnbrn]

Rolen. Great third basemen that stay healthy (coughglauscough) are hard to find.

[nettleman]

I'd probably go with Rolen too, but Cabrera has enormous potential. I know the guy that got Pujols 2 years ago in our keeper league is pretty happy with his decision right now.

Throw Zambrano out of that equation.

[DITKA ®]

If you are able to keep 5, how can you only choose one of the them. Do you have 4 other better players or something?

[Ernest Nzigamasabo]

These are the other 4 players I'm keeping:


Carlos Beltran
Johan Santana
Bobby Abreu
Miguel Tejada


I need to make a decison on the final guy...any complaints with the 4 I'm keeping so far?